Rental Equipment vs. Ownership

If you need a machine for two days a year, owning it is hard to justify. If you need it every week, renting gets old fast. Most farms land somewhere in between.

Key points

Rent rarely used or specialized machines, own the ones you need on short notice.
Compare full rental cost, including delivery, fees and your time.
Inspect and document condition before you leave the yard.
Ask your insurance agent about rented equipment.

When does renting equipment make more sense than owning?

Renting tends to win for specialized or expensive machines used rarely, such as a stump grinder, a trencher or a large tillage tool you need once a year. You pay only when you use it, and someone else stores and maintains it.

It also suits a trial. If you are thinking of buying a type of machine, a rental lets you learn what it can and cannot do before committing.

Specialty rental yards often stock machines a farm rarely needs, such as post-hole augers, chippers and tilt trailers. Call ahead and ask what is available in your area before the busy season.

When does owning make more sense?

Ownership wins when you need the equipment often or at times when rental yards are empty. Hay season is the classic example: when the weather turns, every neighbor wants the same baler on the same day, and you cannot count on one being available.

Timing matters as much as cost. A machine in your own shed is ready the moment conditions are right.

Renting may also protect you from machine obsolescence. If a technology you need changes quickly, you avoid being stuck with an older model.

How do you compare rental cost with ownership cost?

Work out your own cost per hour from your records, including insurance, storage, depreciation, fuel, repairs and labor. Then compare it against rental charges for the same hours, including delivery and pickup.

Count the full rental cost: fees for the day or week, fuel, cleaning charges, damage waivers and transport. Count your time driving to the yard as well.

A rental yard may require a deposit and a credit check, and may charge for late returns. Ask about those terms before you commit to a date.

Rental rate for the period you actually need
Delivery, pickup or your own trailer costs
Fuel and cleaning charges at return
Damage waiver or required insurance
Your travel time and the risk of delay

What should you check before you rent a machine?

Walk around the machine with the rental staff before you leave the yard. Look at tires, hoses, lights, guards and safety devices, and note any damage on the paperwork so you are not charged for it later.

Ask for the operator's manual or a quick walkthrough of the controls, particularly on equipment you have never used.

Take dated photos of the machine on all sides, including the hour meter, and email them to yourself. If a damage dispute comes up later, you have proof of the condition at pickup.

Fluid levels and visible leaks
Shields, guards, ROPS and seat belt in place and working
Lights, brakes and any warning decals
Hour meter reading recorded on the agreement
Terms for breakdowns and replacement
Who is responsible for damage and theft

How do you operate rented equipment safely?

Unfamiliar machines cause accidents. Take extra time to learn the controls, the stopping behavior and the limits on slopes and loads before you start real work. Never skip the seat belt on a ROPS machine, and keep bystanders and children well away.

Do not remove or bypass any safety device because it is in your way. Follow the manufacturer's manual, and use guidance from OSHA, NIOSH and your state extension service.

What does your insurance say about rented equipment?

Do not assume your policy covers equipment you rent. Ask your insurance agent before you rent something expensive, and ask the rental company what it requires.

A damage waiver from the rental company may be worth considering, and your agent can explain how it fits with your own coverage.

Is a mix of renting and owning the best answer?

For many small farms it is. Own the tractor and the few implements you use constantly, and rent the specialized ones. Revisit the decision each year as your work changes.

If you find yourself renting the same machine again and again, run the numbers on buying it, or on sharing it with neighbors.

When to get help: Ask your insurance agent how rented equipment is covered, and ask the rental company to walk you through the controls and safety features. For cost comparisons, an accountant or extension farm management specialist can review your numbers.

Sources and further reading

Organization homepages are linked so you can search them for current guidance on this topic.

More in Ownership, Business & Reviews

← Leasing vs. Buying Equipment Sharing Equipment with Neighbors →