Planter vs. Drill

Both machines put seed in the ground, but they do it differently. Knowing the difference helps you pick the right tool for your crops and acres.

Key points

Planters place seeds at set spacing; drills meter by volume.
Row crops lean to planters; small grains and forage lean to drills.
Match the machine to crops, acres, seedbed and tractor.
Try renting before you buy.

What is the main difference between a planter and a drill?

A planter places seed in individual rows with set spacing, one seed at a time or close to it. A drill places seed in narrow rows and meters it by volume, so seeds fall in a stream rather than at exact spacing.

That difference drives everything else: the crops each handles best, the cost, the speed and the setup work.

Seed size and shape drive the choice. A seed that is large, round and uniform meters well in a planter. A seed that is tiny, fluffy or irregular is better handled by a drill or broadcast seeder.

Which crops suit a planter?

Planters suit crops that need defined spacing, such as corn, soybeans, sunflowers and many vegetables, depending on the unit. Row spacing also lets you cultivate between rows or run a sprayer on a pattern.

If your plans include row cultivation or a precise plant population, a planter is the likely tool.

The row spacing matters, too. Planters are often set up for row spacings that fit a cultivator or sprayer. Drills use narrower spacings that close the canopy sooner and shade out weeds in some crops.

Which crops suit a drill?

Drills handle small grains, forage seed, cover crops and many pasture mixes. They can plant narrow rows quickly and with a wide range of seed sizes. Many drills also come in no-till versions for sod and stubble.

A hay grower thickening a stand or a rancher renovating a pasture will usually reach for a drill.

Drill seeding is also common after hay harvest, when a farmer wants to establish a cover or a summer annual quickly. Ask your extension office which seeding method local trials favor for your crop.

How do cost, speed and setup compare?

Planters often have more parts per row, so setup, adjustment and maintenance take more time. Drills are usually simpler, but a no-till drill is still heavy and needs a solid tractor.

Think about both machines' working width, how many acres you plant and your planting window. Ask a dealer for tractor requirements and parts availability.

Maintenance is a real cost. Row units, sensors, seed tubes and drive chains all need attention on a planter. A drill's maintenance centers on openers, meters and bearings. Count the hours you will spend, not only the purchase price. Transport and storage matter. Both can be wide when unfolded. Check your state DOT rules for width, lighting and marking for farm equipment on public roads, and measure your shed door before you buy.

Planters: more precise, more parts, more setup
Drills: simpler metering, many seed types
Check the tractor requirements for each
Compare parts support locally

What about small farms and homesteads?

A 5-acre homestead growing mixed crops may need only a small seeder or a rented drill. A 30-acre farm raising corn and soybeans may justify a planter. If your plans change from year to year, a versatile drill or custom hire may be wiser.

Many conservation districts rent drills, which lets you try the process without buying.

A cattle rancher with a few acres of improved pasture usually needs a drill, not a planter. A vegetable grower with several acres of sweet corn may want a planter. A mixed operation might use both, borrowing one and owning the other.

How do you decide between them?

Write down crops, acres, seedbed type and tractor. Then talk to neighbors, your extension office and a dealer. Ask to see each machine at work if you can.

Do not buy a machine because it is available cheap. Buy the one that fits what you actually plant.

Try to see a working demonstration or talk to an owner. Ask what they like, what they would change and what breaks. That kind of local knowledge is worth more than a brochure.

List crops and acres first
Check seedbed and tractor
Ask about rentals and custom work
Visit a working field if possible

What safety points apply to both machines?

Both machines are heavy and have pinch points. Lower the implement to the ground, shut the tractor down, remove the key and wait for all motion to stop before working on it. Use the transport locks or pins specified in the manual, and never work under a raised frame.

Keep children and bystanders away during hitching and filling. Follow your operator's manual and guidance from OSHA, NIOSH and your extension office.

When to get help: If you are unsure about tractor compatibility, ask the dealer service department or the tractor manufacturer. For financing, talk to your lender and your local USDA FSA office.

Sources and further reading

Organization homepages are linked so you can search them for current guidance on this topic.

More in Planting, Seeding & Spraying Equipment

← Seed Spacing and Depth Settings Row Crop Planter Components →